Agema Publications

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Agema Publications

A forum for the disscussion of the Play by Mail games from Agema Publications


+2
jamesbond007
Rozwi_Game10
6 posters

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Rozwi_Game10
    Rozwi_Game10
    King
    King


    Number of posts : 661
    Location : North Yorkshire
    Reputation : 9
    Registration date : 2015-08-15

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Rozwi_Game10 Tue Apr 12, 2016 10:51 am

    Kingmaker wrote:ok sorry deleted the thread for unplayed positions by accident thought I had moved it but it deleted it instead!  affraid

    Please repost if you can  Embarassed

    The gist of it was, which, out of all of the playing positions available, do you know have been played in games of LGDR / TGOK

    Europe
    Kingdom of England                           Kingdom of Scotland
    Kingdom of Sweden                           Kingdom of Denmark
    United Provinces (Dutch Republic)        Kingdom of France
    Kingdom of Spain                              Kingdom of Portugal
    Duchy of Savoy-Piedmont                   Republic of Genoa & St. George
    Republic of Venice & St. Mark              The Papal States (the Papacy/Vatican)
    The Duchy of Tuscany                         The Swiss Cantons
    The Principality of Hanover                  The Principality of Bavaria
    The Principality of Saxony                   The Principality of Hesse-Kassel
    The Principality of Hesse-Darmstadt     The Duchy of Wurtemburg
    The Duchy of Lorraine                        The Holy Roman Emperor (Austria, &c)
    Principality of Prussia-Brandenburg      The Tsardom of Russia
    Principality of Poland (Commonwealth)  Duchy of Lithuania (Commonwealth)
    Polish Ukraine (Commonwealth)          Duchy of Courland (Commonwealth)

    Ottoman -types [As I couldn't decide what name to call them.]
    Ottoman Anatolia (Sultanate)              Ottoman Europe/Rumelia (Sultanate)
    Ottoman Syria (Sultanate)                  Ottoman/Mameluke Egypt (Sultanate)
    Principality of Moldavia (Sultanate)      Principality of Wallachia (Sultanate)
    Khanate of the Crimean Tartars           Shahdom of Persia
    Sultanate of Oman                            Sharif of Hejaz

    India
    Moghul India                                    The Maharatas
    The Rajputs                                     Gujerat
    Afghans

    Africa
    The Asante Union                              Kingdom of the Rozwi
    Empire of the Abyssinians                  

    Asia
    Kingdom of Burma                            Kingdom of Siam
    Shansi province (Imperial China)         Kwantung province (China)
    Shantung province (China)                 Kingdom of Korea (Imperial China)
    Manchuria province (China)                Shogunate of Imperial Japan

    Pirates
    Wako Japanese pirates
    Blackbeard (West Indies pirate)
    William Kidd (West Indies pirate)
    Madagascan pirates

    Exiled
    The Jacobites (in exile)
    The Camisards (Huguenots rebels)


    Last edited by Rozwi_Game10 on Wed Apr 13, 2016 9:40 am; edited 1 time in total
    Rozwi_Game10
    Rozwi_Game10
    King
    King


    Number of posts : 661
    Location : North Yorkshire
    Reputation : 9
    Registration date : 2015-08-15

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Rozwi_Game10 Tue Apr 12, 2016 10:56 am

    Gujerat was given as a position not ever being, possibly, played. And I said that I've reserved that position in a game, but am paying on Thursday when Richard is back at his desk.

    avatar
    jamesbond007
    King
    King


    Number of posts : 634
    Age : 54
    Location : Norwich
    Reputation : 17
    Registration date : 2009-04-07

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by jamesbond007 Tue Apr 12, 2016 1:44 pm

    Well you cannot be in game 8. The position has already been lost, to the Moghul.
    Kingmaker
    Kingmaker
    Admin
    Admin


    Number of posts : 1673
    Age : 67
    Location : Scarborough Jewel of the East Coast
    Reputation : 28
    Registration date : 2008-04-20

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Kingmaker Tue Apr 12, 2016 3:46 pm

    Principality of Poland (Commonwealth)  Duchy of Lithuania (Commonwealth)
    Polish Ukraine (Commonwealth)          Duchy of Courland (Commonwealth)

    all these where played in Game 3 at one time then they all dropped out me included (Poland)
    avatar
    Stuart Bailey
    Emperor of Europe
    Emperor of Europe


    Number of posts : 2606
    Age : 61
    Location : Somewhere East of Bristol & West of Bath
    Reputation : 61
    Registration date : 2012-01-29

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Stuart Bailey Wed Apr 13, 2016 12:01 am

    Rozwi_Game10 wrote:Gujerat was given as a position not ever being, possibly, played. And I said that I've reserved that position in a game, but am paying on Thursday when Richard is back at his desk.



    Are you sure calling the Great Shah of Persia "Ottoman-ish" and then taking a position next to said King of Kings & the Great Iman of the House of Ali is a good diplomatic move?......well its one way to liven up the game in India......bring forward the Invasions of Nadar Shah and Ahmed Shah by 40 years.

    Have to admit I think more Persian players should consider heading East looking for loot, plunder, and glory for smiteing the ungodly. Since while its next to impossible to get the Afghans, Uzbecks etc to co-operate over anything they do seem to be up for a Jihad over the Hindu Kush.

    Jokes at the expense of would be rulers of Gujerat to one side I understand that in its early days Glori du Roi was a lot more Euro-Centric and players used to get double positions like Wurtenburg-Portugal or Hesse-Kessel-Malta so if one part of your position got crushed you could run away and rebuild.

    I suspect that some of the more minor German states have been played in this form but not since & I still can not believe that someone
    actually played Courland in G3.........its a sand dune! With possible sea side development by the Czar if his other favoured options do not work out.
    Rozwi_Game10
    Rozwi_Game10
    King
    King


    Number of posts : 661
    Location : North Yorkshire
    Reputation : 9
    Registration date : 2015-08-15

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Rozwi_Game10 Wed Apr 13, 2016 10:04 am

    jamesbond007 wrote:Well you cannot be in game 8. The position has already been lost, to the Moghul.

    Yes, that's what I was told when I made enquiries for the position.

    Game 8 was out, due to what you've said, and I was already taking part in game 10.

    Stuart Bailey wrote:Are you sure calling the Great Shah of Persia "Ottoman-ish" and then taking a position next to said King of Kings & the Great Iman of the House of Ali is a good diplomatic move?

    I was stuck for what to label them. Middle-East, but the Crimean location scotches that. Islamic States, wouldn't have been correct as there's other states elsewhere with Islam as a main religion. I'm happy to modify my original post, if anyone can provide a more suitable name.

    ###

    Below. I've striked out any game positions I've either played against or heard tell of.
    The player positions in the different font are those awaiting confirmation of them having been played - and I can update, or someone else can.


    Europe
    Kingdom of England                          
    Kingdom of Scotland
    Kingdom of Sweden                          
    Kingdom of Denmark
    United Provinces (Dutch Republic)      
    Kingdom of France
    Kingdom of Spain                            
    Kingdom of Portugal
    Duchy of Savoy-Piedmont                  
    Republic of Genoa & St. George
    Republic of Venice & St. Mark            
    The Papal States (the Papacy/Vatican)
    The Duchy of Tuscany                        
    The Swiss Cantons
    The Principality of Hanover                  
    The Principality of Bavaria
    The Principality of Saxony                  
    The Principality of Hesse-Kassel
    The Principality of Hesse-Darmstadt  
    The Duchy of Wurtemburg
    The Duchy of Lorraine                        
    The Holy Roman Emperor (Austria, &c)
    Principality of Prussia-Brandenburg    
    The Tsardom of Russia
    Principality of Poland (Commonwealth)  
    Duchy of Lithuania (Commonwealth)
    Polish Ukraine (Commonwealth)          
    Duchy of Courland (Commonwealth)

    I couldn't decide what name to call them
    Ottoman Anatolia (Sultanate)              
    Ottoman Europe/Rumelia (Sultanate)
    Ottoman Syria(Sultanate)                  
    Ottoman/Mameluke Egypt (Sultanate)
    Principality of Moldavia (Sultanate)      
    Principality of Wallachia (Sultanate)      
    Khanate of the Crimean Tartars     
    Shahdom of Persia
    Sultanate of Oman                            
    Sharif of Hejaz

    India
    Moghul India                                  
    The Maharatas
    The Rajputs                                    
    Gujerat
    Afghans


    Africa
    The Asante Union                            
    Kingdom of the Rozwi
    Empire of the Abyssinians                  

    Asia
    Kingdom of Burma                            
    Kingdom of Siam
    Shansi province (Imperial China)        
    Kwantung province (China)
    Shantung province (China)                
    Kingdom of Korea (Imperial China)
    Manchuria province(China)                
    Shogunate of Imperial Japan

    Pirates
    Wako Japanese pirates
    Blackbeard (West Indies pirate)
    William Kidd (West Indies pirate)
    Madagascan pirates


    Exiled
    The Jacobites (in exile)
    The Camisards (Huguenots rebels)


    Last edited by Rozwi_Game10 on Sat Apr 23, 2016 6:37 pm; edited 3 times in total
    avatar
    Guest
    Guest


    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Guest Sat Apr 16, 2016 4:45 pm

    I have played Hanover, Manchuria and Moldova. I know the Maharatas, Bavaria, Burma, Siam and Korea have been played and certain Shansi Province has been too.

    Has anyone ever played Lorraine? Can't recall it and I've always imagined it would be too much under risk from French attack to play
    Deacon
    Deacon
    Emperor
    Emperor


    Number of posts : 1859
    Age : 61
    Location : Portland OR, USA
    Reputation : 44
    Registration date : 2010-04-13

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Deacon Sat Apr 16, 2016 5:36 pm


    Korea was played for a time in game 8.
    Sharif was played for a time in game 8.
    Ottoman Syria was played in game 8. (think it still might be, don't know)
    Ottoman Anatolia is played in game 8.
    Burma was played in game 8.
    avatar
    Stuart Bailey
    Emperor of Europe
    Emperor of Europe


    Number of posts : 2606
    Age : 61
    Location : Somewhere East of Bristol & West of Bath
    Reputation : 61
    Registration date : 2012-01-29

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Stuart Bailey Sat Apr 16, 2016 7:36 pm

    Ref unplayed positions:

    Europe

    I can confirm that I have seen all the listed positions played apart from Hesse-Kessel & Wurtemburg. Who both seem landlocked Imperial states without a lot to recommend them.

    From back copies of G2 I ordered when joining this game I believe Lorraine was played for a short while as a French Ally in G2. This was the odd period when France declared a Republic and attempted to fight the revolutionary wars 100 years early. Not a great success I understand.

    Aside from this odd situation I wonder if Lorraine is more playable as a junior French position rather than as a Gernan State?

    Naturally a lot depends on the main French Player. Some players hate shared positions and view junior positions hanging round their court or running a trade company as rivals to be crushed. But some others dont seem to mind.

    If anyone fancies running the House of Orleans (Lorraine) G10 seems like a good option......since if the French Monarchy in G10 does not seem bothered by Jacobites & Corsairs its probably happy to play nice with some of the Kings relatives.


    India

    - Have only known Moguls,Mahra & Persians played and non of the smaller positions which I think is a pity since the C18 is a very interesting period in Indian History inc the biggest battle of the century.


    Ottomans

    - We seem to have ticked off everyone apart from Oman and perhaps Wallachia. Recall a Kingdom of Rumania in G2 which may have started life as Wallachia? Or Moldavia?
    Kingmaker
    Kingmaker
    Admin
    Admin


    Number of posts : 1673
    Age : 67
    Location : Scarborough Jewel of the East Coast
    Reputation : 28
    Registration date : 2008-04-20

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Kingmaker Sat Apr 16, 2016 8:57 pm

    seen Wurtemburg played in game 3 he took over Saxony as well so a joint Principlality
    Basileus
    Basileus
    Prince
    Prince


    Number of posts : 458
    Age : 63
    Location : Wales/Cornwall
    Reputation : 13
    Registration date : 2011-07-01

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Basileus Sat Apr 23, 2016 7:13 am

    Hesse Kassel is also a live position in game 10.
    Rozwi_Game10
    Rozwi_Game10
    King
    King


    Number of posts : 661
    Location : North Yorkshire
    Reputation : 9
    Registration date : 2015-08-15

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Rozwi_Game10 Sat Apr 23, 2016 9:50 am

    Thank you, everyone, for your input. I believe I've updated the list correctly.

    As to my own interest in Gujerat, I decided to not take the position and only play in Game 10.

    I prefer the limited build options of the Rozwi position and the more, singular game route offered by this African position. I've played other states in the past where the full options of construction and research was available to me and I, honestly, didn't know where to focus and lost myself pursuing too many things. In the past, I found playing as a Pirate a lot easier than playing as a state, but I didn't play the position wisely nor as ruthlessly as I possibly should have.

    Kingmaker
    Kingmaker
    Admin
    Admin


    Number of posts : 1673
    Age : 67
    Location : Scarborough Jewel of the East Coast
    Reputation : 28
    Registration date : 2008-04-20

    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Kingmaker Sat Apr 23, 2016 11:53 am

    Principality of Wallachia (Sultanate)                   [possibly been played]
    Khanate of the Crimean Tartars 

    these have been played, think I played Tartars breifly

    Sponsored content


    Which TGOK game positions have never been played? Empty Re: Which TGOK game positions have never been played?

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Fri Nov 22, 2024 9:48 am